
Every year, the first box of holiday decor comes down from the attic and I want my whole house to smell like a Christmas tree farm. That’s why I started hunting for Thymes Frasier Fir candle alternatives. The Thymes candle is a cult favorite for good reason. It smells like fresh cut fir, cedar and a hint of sandalwood.
The catch? The classic Pine Needle candle is $37 for just 6.5 ounces, and many of us burn candles all season long. So I rounded up 5 fir and balsam candles from Amazon and Walmart that bring that cozy tree lot scent home for less. Prices start at only $9.98.
Why Everyone Loves the Thymes Frasier Fir Candle
Thymes launched Frasier Fir years ago, and it has become a holiday tradition in so many homes. For reference, the Frasier Fir Pine Needle candle is $37 right now on the Thymes website. Here’s why fans keep coming back:
- True fir scent: it smells like a real tree, not a sugary pine air freshener.
- Pretty packaging: the green glass with the pine needle pattern looks festive on a mantel.
- Strong throw: fans love how well the scent fills a room.
- Clean burn: it burns evenly with a steady flame.
- Gift worthy: it’s a classic hostess gift, teacher gift and stocking stuffer.
What to Look for in a Thymes Frasier Fir Candle Alternative
Fir candles can smell wildly different from brand to brand. Here’s what I pay attention to before buying.
- Scent notes: look for fir, balsam, cedar or pine. Skip anything with heavy cinnamon or vanilla if you want that crisp tree smell.
- Size and burn time: a large jar costs less per hour of burn time. Compare ounces, not just price.
- Wick: a wooden wick crackles like a fireplace. Cotton wicks are quieter and very reliable.
- Throw: read reviews about how far the scent travels. Some candles smell great cold but fade once lit.
- Jar style: green glass or amber glass looks pretty with holiday decor and can be reused later.
The 5 Best Thymes Frasier Fir Candle Alternatives
Village Candle Balsam Fir Large Apothecary Jar Candle, $21.95

Village Candle Balsam Fir is the pick I’d grab first. It’s a big 21.25 ounce apothecary jar in deep green glass, so it looks festive right away. It also has more than 7,000 reviews with a 4.6 star rating.
Balsam fir is the classic Christmas tree scent, so it’s a natural swap. Plus, you get more than three times the wax of the Thymes candle for less money.
Best for: the best overall value.
Yankee Candle Balsam and Cedar Large Jar Candle, $19.95

Yankee Candle Balsam and Cedar is a holiday classic. It blends balsam fir with cedar wood, which gives it a woodsy, outdoorsy feel. The 22 ounce jar is under $20, and it has a 4.6 star rating from over 2,800 reviewers.
It leans a bit more cedar than the Thymes candle. Still, if you love that cozy cabin smell, this one is a winner.
Best for: a woodsy cabin vibe.
Sweet Water Decor Fraser Fir Candle, $19.99

This Sweet Water Decor candle is the closest in spirit to Thymes. It’s a Fraser fir scent poured into a chic amber jar, and it looks lovely on a bathroom counter or nightstand. The 9 ounce size is a nice middle ground.
It has about 100 reviews and a 4.2 star average, so there’s less feedback than the big brands. That said, the simple Fraser fir scent is a nice match for anyone who prefers crisp over sweet.
Best for: a modern, minimal look.
WoodWick Fraser Fir 16 oz Ellipse Candle, $24.87

WoodWick’s Fraser Fir candle has a wooden wick that crackles while it burns. That sound alone makes it feel like Christmas. The 16 ounce ellipse jar has three wicks and a soft green color.
It has over 4,700 reviews and a 4.6 star rating at Walmart. Like most wooden wicks, it burns best when you trim it before each use. Still, it’s a fan favorite every December.
Best for: a crackling fireplace feel.
Better Homes and Gardens Apple Frasier Fir Jar Candle, $9.98

This Better Homes and Gardens Apple Frasier Fir candle is under $10, which is amazing. It’s a 6 ounce single wick jar, so it’s close in size to the Thymes candle. The scent mixes fir with a touch of crisp apple.
It has about 50 reviews with a 4.7 star average. Because of the apple note, it’s a little fruitier than Thymes. Even so, it’s a sweet stocking stuffer at this price.
Best for: stocking stuffers on a budget.
How to Decorate With Your Fir Candle
A fir candle is the easiest way to make your home feel festive. Here are a few ways I’d style one:
- Mantel moment: tuck a large jar into garland with pinecones and a few twinkle lights.
- Entryway welcome: light one before guests arrive so the first thing they notice is that tree lot scent.
- Bathroom refresh: a small jar on the counter makes even a powder room feel cozy for the holidays.
- Gift basket: pair a candle with cocoa, a mug and a cozy throw for an easy hostess gift.
Want more seasonal decor ideas? My Mr. Christmas ceramic tree alternatives look adorable next to a glowing candle. And if you love a good scent, my Capri Blue Volcano candle look alikes are worth a peek too.
One more tip from me: keep your candles away from drafty windows and fresh garland. That keeps the flame steady and safe. Also, never leave a lit candle alone with kids or pets nearby. A little care means your favorite scent lasts all season.
Frequently Asked Questions
What candle smells like Thymes Frasier Fir?
Village Candle Balsam Fir and the Sweet Water Decor Fraser Fir candle are the closest picks. Both lean fresh and green rather than sweet. WoodWick Fraser Fir is another great match if you like a crackling wick.
Does Walmart have a Thymes Frasier Fir candle look alike?
Yes! Walmart carries the WoodWick Fraser Fir candle and the Better Homes and Gardens Apple Frasier Fir candle. The Better Homes and Gardens jar is under $10.
Is the Thymes Frasier Fir candle worth it?
Many fans say yes, because the scent is so true to a real tree. However, if you burn candles every night in December, a larger jar like Village Candle gives you far more burn time for less.
How do I make a candle burn evenly?
Let it burn until the wax melts all the way to the edge the first time, usually two to three hours. Then trim the wick to about a quarter inch before each burn.
Which fir candle is the best gift?
The Village Candle jar looks the most like a classic holiday gift, thanks to the green glass and big size. For a more modern friend, wrap up the Sweet Water Decor candle with a bow. Then, for coworkers or teachers, the Better Homes and Gardens jar keeps the budget in check.
How long does a large fir candle last?
A 21 or 22 ounce jar usually lasts somewhere between 100 and 150 hours, depending on the wick. That’s why the Village Candle and Yankee Candle jars are such a good deal. By comparison, a smaller 6 ounce jar burns for roughly 35 to 45 hours.
Final Thoughts
If I had to pick one, Village Candle Balsam Fir is the best value, with a huge jar and thousands of happy reviews. For the most modern look, I’d choose the Sweet Water Decor candle. Then, for stocking stuffers, the Better Homes and Gardens jar is a steal.
Find even more designer looks for less in my ultimate guide to designer alternatives.
Disclosure: Please note that some of the links above are affiliate links. At no additional cost to you, I will earn a commission if you purchase after clicking through the link.
You May Also Like
Love a cozy home that smells amazing? Don’t miss my candles that smell like Diptyque. My Pottery Barn velvet pumpkins alternatives are also perfect for fall decorating.





