6 Summer Fridays Lip Balm Alternatives You Will Love for Less

Summer Fridays lip balm alternatives: three pink, peach and cream lip balm tubes on a white marble vanity

The minute the heat kicks on in our house, my lips are done for. I keep a balm in the car, one by the sink and one in every coat pocket. So it’s no surprise that the Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm is all over my feed. Still, $24 for a lip balm adds up fast. That’s why I went looking for Summer Fridays lip balm alternatives that cost a lot less.

Below you’ll find 6 picks I’d happily toss in my bag. Three are from Amazon and three are from Walmart. They start at just $4.97, and a few are buttery tubes that look a lot like the original. Plus, they make really cute stocking stuffers.

Why Everyone Loves the Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm

This balm took off for a reason. It’s a thick, glossy lip butter in a soft squeeze tube. It also works as both a daytime balm and an overnight mask. For reference, the original Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm is $24 right now on the brand site.

  • Buttery texture: It feels plush and rich, not waxy or sticky.
  • Shea and murumuru butters: These plant butters are what make lips feel soft and conditioned.
  • Glossy finish: You get a pretty shine without the tack of a lip gloss.
  • Fun flavors and tints: It comes in several scents and sheer shades, so people collect them.
  • Cute packaging: The soft tube looks so pretty on a vanity or peeking out of a purse.

What to Look for in a Summer Fridays Lip Balm Alternative

Not every cheap balm feels the same, even among Summer Fridays lip balm alternatives. Here’s what I pay attention to before I add one to my cart.

  • Butters first: Look for shea, murumuru or cocoa butter near the top of the list. That’s where the soft, plush feel comes from.
  • Hydrators: Hyaluronic acid, peptides and ceramides are a nice bonus. They help lips feel smooth for longer.
  • Finish: Decide if you want clear shine or a hint of color. Some of these picks are tinted, and some are sheer.
  • Packaging: A squeeze tube is the closest match. A pot with a spatula is great for nighttime, but it’s messier on the go.
  • Reviews: Thousands of ratings tell you a lot. Reviewers are quick to call out a balm that feels sticky or smells too strong.

The 6 Best Summer Fridays Lip Balm Alternatives

I picked these based on ingredients, finish and real reviewer feedback. Each one has a different strength, so read the “Best for” line to find your match. Prices were checked today and can change quickly around the holidays.

e.l.f. SKIN Holy Hydration! Lip Mask, $8.00

e.l.f. SKIN Holy Hydration Lip Mask in a pot with applicator from Amazon

Shop at Amazon

If you love using Summer Fridays as an overnight mask, start here. This e.l.f. lip mask is a leave-on formula with hyaluronic acid. It has a sweet berry scent and comes with a little applicator.

The listing says it’s silky and non-sticky, and it has over 5,700 ratings with a 4.6 star average. Reviewers like wearing it to bed and waking up to softer lips. Just know it’s a pot, not a tube.

Best for: overnight lip care for under $10.

Vitamasques Lip Butter Balm, $4.97

Vitamasques Lip Butter Balm in Vanilla Bean from Walmart, a Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm alternative

Shop at Walmart

This is the one I’d grab first. The name says it all, and the Vanilla Bean flavor is such a cozy match for the original. It comes in a soft squeeze tube and costs about a fifth of the price.

It’s made with ceramides, peptides and a hyaluronic complex. Walmart reviewers give it 4.7 stars from more than 500 ratings. There are four flavors, so you can grab a couple without feeling guilty.

Best for: the closest vanilla look for less.

e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm, $5.00

e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm in Strawberry from Amazon, an affordable lip butter balm look alike

Shop at Amazon

Next up is a true fan favorite. The Squeeze Me Lip Balm has almost 23,000 ratings on Amazon and a 4.6 star average. That’s a lot of happy lips!

It has shea butter and hyaluronic acid, and it gives a sheer wash of color. The squeeze tube is so similar in feel to the original. At $5, I’d keep one in my purse and one in the car.

Best for: an everyday purse balm.

NatureWell Tinted Lip Butter, $6.88

NatureWell Tinted Lip Butter in Pink Velvet from Walmart, a Summer Fridays lip balm alternative

Shop at Walmart

Here’s a fun surprise. Like the original, this tinted lip butter uses shea butter and murumuru butter, plus vitamin E. The Pink Velvet shade adds a soft pop of color with shine.

It has over 800 reviews and a 4.6 star rating at Walmart. The tube is a generous 0.53 oz too. I think it’s a great pick for school drop off when you want to look a little put together.

Best for: tinted shine with the same plant butters.

NYX Professional Makeup Fat Oil Slick Click, $11.49

NYX Fat Oil Slick Click tinted lip balm from Amazon in a click up pen

Shop at Amazon

Want more color? This one sits somewhere between a balm and a lip oil. It’s in click up packaging, so you get just the right amount each time.

The listing promises up to 12 hours of hydration and buildable color. It has close to 5,900 ratings with a 4.4 star average. It’s the priciest pick here, but it still costs about half of the original.

Best for: balmy color for date night.

eos Cashmere Lip Butter, $6.99

eos Cashmere Lip Butter in Strawberry Dream from Walmart, an affordable lip butter

Shop at Walmart

Last, this eos lip butter is so sweet. The Strawberry Dream flavor is described as sparkling strawberry, pink sugar and vanilla cream. It has peptides and a plush, smooth feel.

It’s newer, so it has about 120 reviews, but they average a lovely 4.8 stars. The packaging feels a little fancy, which makes it a great gift. I’d tuck one into a stocking or a teacher gift bag.

Best for: stocking stuffers and gifting.

How to Use Your Lip Balm Alternative

A good lip butter does more than you’d think. Here’s how I’d put these Summer Fridays lip balm alternatives to work all winter.

  • As an overnight mask: Apply a thick layer before bed. The e.l.f. Holy Hydration mask is perfect for this.
  • Under lipstick: Pat on a thin layer and blot before color. If you love a nude lip, my Pillow Talk lipstick alternatives pair well with these.
  • On its own for shine: A tinted pick like NatureWell or NYX is all you need for a quick, polished look.
  • In a self care gift: Bundle one with a body cream. My Sol de Janeiro Bum Bum Cream alternatives make easy add ons.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is similar to the Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm?

The Vitamasques Lip Butter Balm is the most similar, with a squeeze tube and a vanilla flavor for $4.97. The NatureWell Tinted Lip Butter is also close because it uses shea and murumuru butters too.

Does Walmart have a Summer Fridays lip balm look alike?

Yes! Walmart carries the Vitamasques Lip Butter Balm, the NatureWell Tinted Lip Butter and the eos Cashmere Lip Butter. All three are under $7 and well reviewed.

Is the Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm worth $24?

If you love the packaging and the exact flavors, it’s a fun treat. Still, the drugstore picks above give you a buttery, glossy feel for a lot less. You could buy three or four of them for the price of one.

Can you use a lip butter balm as an overnight lip mask?

Absolutely. Just apply a thicker layer at night. The e.l.f. Holy Hydration Lip Mask is made for this, and the Squeeze Me balm works well too. For more overnight options, see my Laneige Lip Sleeping Mask alternatives.

Final Thoughts

Out of all these Summer Fridays lip balm alternatives, if I had to pick just one, I’d grab the Vitamasques Lip Butter Balm for the best value. It’s $4.97 and feels the most like the original. For the best overall, the e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm has thousands of happy reviewers. And if you want a pop of color, the NYX Fat Oil Slick Click is the standout.

Love a glossy lip? You might also like my Dior Lip Glow Oil alternatives for even more shine.

Discover more designer look alikes in my ultimate guide to designer look alikes for less.

Disclosure: Please note that some of the links above are affiliate links. At no additional cost to you, I will earn a commission if you purchase after clicking through the link.

You May Also Like

Building a beauty wish list? Don’t miss my Laneige Lip Sleeping Mask alternatives for more overnight lip care, or my Kylie lip kit alternatives if you love a matte lip.

Leave a Comment