6 Hill House Nap Dress Alternatives You Will Love for Less

Hill House Nap Dress alternatives: sage gingham smocked midi dress with puff sleeves on a hanger in a sunny bedroom

Every December, my calendar fills up fast. There’s the school holiday program, a cookie swap, brunch with friends and at least one family photo session. On those days I want a dress that feels like pajamas but still looks pulled together. That’s exactly why the Hill House Nap Dress became such a cult favorite, and why I went looking for the best Hill House Nap Dress alternatives.

The original is lovely, but the classic Ellie Nap Dress is $178 at full price. I rounded up 6 look alikes from Amazon and Walmart with the same smocked bodice, puff sleeves and tiered skirt. Prices start at just $7.50, so you could grab two or three for the cost of one.

Why Everyone Loves the Hill House Nap Dress

Hill House turned a simple smocked dress into a full fashion moment. It’s comfortable enough to lounge in, yet it photographs beautifully. For reference, the Ellie Nap Dress is $178 right now, and the Ellie Maxi Nap Dress runs $198 to $228. Some prints do go on sale, but most stay near full price.

  • Smocked bodice: The stretchy smocking hugs your shape without any zippers or buttons.
  • Puff sleeves: Short, ruffled sleeves give it that sweet, romantic look.
  • Tiered skirt: The full, swingy midi skirt hides a holiday cookie or two. Yes, really.
  • Square neckline: It frames your face and works with a simple necklace.
  • Easy care: Most versions are cotton, so they wash well and feel breathable.

What to Look for in a Nap Dress Alternative

Not every smocked dress gives the same effect. Here is what I check before adding one to my cart.

  • Fabric: Cotton or a soft woven feels closest to the original. Very thin polyester can look cheap in photos.
  • Smocking: Look for a fully smocked bodice. That stretch is what makes these dresses so comfortable.
  • Length: A true midi hits mid calf. Check the length chart, especially if you are petite or tall.
  • Sleeves: Short puff sleeves feel classic. For winter, a long sleeve smocked dress is easier to layer.
  • Fit and reviews: Read reviews for sizing notes. Many of these run roomy through the skirt.

The 6 Best Hill House Nap Dress Alternatives

MEROKEETY Puff Sleeve Tiered Midi Dress, $39.99

Pink smocked puff sleeve tiered midi dress from Amazon, a Hill House Nap Dress alternative

Shop at Amazon

This is the one I would grab first. It has a smocked bodice, short puff sleeves and a two tier skirt that flares just like the original. Over 3,300 shoppers have rated it, with an average of 4.2 stars.

The listing calls the neckline a crewneck, so it sits a little higher than a classic nap dress. Still, the overall shape is very close. It comes in solids and florals, and the pink is so pretty for Valentine’s Day too.

Best for: the closest everyday match.

Time and Tru Square Neck Puff Sleeve Midi Dress, $7.50

Light blue square neck puff sleeve midi dress from Walmart, a Hill House Nap Dress look alike

Shop at Walmart

Yes, this Walmart find is under ten dollars right now. It has the square neckline, short puff sleeves and tiered midi skirt that make the original so recognizable. Plus, it’s 100% cotton, which is rare at this price.

There’s an elastic waist and a back tie at the neckline, so you can adjust the fit. It has a 4.4 star rating from around 360 reviews. Prices on Walmart clearance change quickly, so check the current price before you check out.

Best for: the best value by far.

ZESICA Gingham Puff Sleeve Square Neck Midi Dress, $33.79

Green gingham square neck puff sleeve midi dress from Amazon, a Hill House Nap Dress alternative

Shop at Amazon

Gingham is one of the most loved Hill House prints, and this ZESICA dress nails that look. It has a smocked square neck bodice, big puff sleeves and a tiered ruffle skirt.

It has nearly 3,000 ratings and a 4.2 star average. Reviewers often mention the skirt is very full, so it feels swishy and fun. The green gingham reads cozy for winter, then easily carries into spring.

Best for: gingham lovers and family photos.

Time and Tru Smocked Bodice Midi Woven Dress, $8.17

Red floral smocked bodice midi dress with flutter sleeves from Walmart, a nap dress alternative

Shop at Walmart

This one is another budget pick from Walmart. The bodice is smocked with shirring at the bottom, and a ruffled crewneck adds a sweet detail. Short flutter sleeves keep it soft and feminine.

With over 1,000 reviews and a 4.5 star rating, it’s a shopper favorite. It’s made of rayon, so it drapes nicely. It also comes in plus sizes up to 4X, which makes it a great option for more bodies.

Best for: plus size options on a budget.

Zattcas Long Sleeve Smocked Floral Midi Dress, $39.99

Green floral long sleeve smocked midi dress from Amazon, a holiday nap dress alternative

Shop at Amazon

If you want the nap dress feeling in December, a long sleeve version makes so much sense. This Zattcas dress has a stretchy smocked bodice and smocked cuffs. Then the tiered midi skirt adds that signature swing.

It has a 4.4 star rating from about 1,390 reviews. The dainty floral print looks especially pretty in the darker colors. Add tights and ankle boots, and you’re ready for a holiday party.

Best for: cold weather and holiday events.

PRETTYGARDEN Long Sleeve Smocked Swiss Dot Maxi Dress, $56.99

Cream long sleeve smocked swiss dot maxi dress from Walmart, a nap dress look alike

Shop at Walmart

For something a little more dressed up, this maxi version is gorgeous. It has a square neckline, a smocked bodice, long sleeves and a tiered ruffle skirt. The swiss dot texture adds a lovely detail up close.

It’s also the only pick here with pockets. It has a 4.2 star rating from about 120 reviews, so there’s less feedback than the others. That’s why I’d check the size chart carefully before ordering.

Best for: a maxi look with pockets.

How to Style Your Nap Dress Alternative

The best part about a nap dress is how easily it changes with the season. Here are a few ways I love to wear the look.

  • Cozy winter layers: Add a chunky cardigan, tights and ankle boots. My Sezane Gaspard cardigan alternatives pair perfectly with a smocked dress.
  • Holiday party: Choose a long sleeve style in a deep color. Then add pearl earrings, a velvet bow and a heeled loafer.
  • Weekend errands: Wear a short sleeve version with a denim jacket and white sneakers. It’s easy, comfy and still feels polished.
  • Spring and summer: Swap to sandals, a straw tote and a simple gold necklace. For more romantic prairie styles, see my Doen dress alternatives.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is similar to the Hill House Nap Dress?

Look for a smocked bodice, puff sleeves and a tiered midi skirt. The MEROKEETY puff sleeve midi dress and the ZESICA gingham midi dress are two of the closest matches on Amazon.

Does Walmart have a Hill House Nap Dress look alike?

Yes! The Time and Tru square neck puff sleeve midi dress has the square neckline, puff sleeves and tiered skirt for under ten dollars. For a long sleeve option, the PRETTYGARDEN swiss dot maxi dress is also sold at Walmart.

Is the Hill House Nap Dress worth the price?

It’s well made, and the prints are beautiful. However, at $178 it is a splurge for a casual dress. If you want the look for everyday wear, the alternatives here cost a fraction of the price.

Do nap dresses run big?

Many smocked dresses feel roomy because the skirt is so full. Still, the stretchy bodice fits a range of sizes. Check each size chart, and read reviews for notes on length and fit.

Final Thoughts

If I had to pick, the Time and Tru square neck dress is the best value. The MEROKEETY tiered midi dress is my best overall pick for that classic shape. And for the holidays, I love the Zattcas long sleeve smocked dress. Each one gives you that soft, feminine nap dress look for much less.

Also, if you love comfy pieces that still look put together, my Reformation dress alternatives have more pretty options to browse.

Discover more designer look alikes in my ultimate guide to designer alternatives for less.

Disclosure: Please note that some of the links above are affiliate links. At no additional cost to you, I will earn a commission if you purchase after clicking through the link.

You May Also Like

Love a cozy, feminine look? Don’t miss my Eberjey Gisele pajamas alternatives for soft holiday loungewear. You might also like my Barefoot Dreams cardigan look alikes, which layer beautifully over a smocked dress.

Leave a Comment