5 Free People Good Luck Barrel Jeans Alternatives You Will Love

Free People Good Luck barrel jeans alternatives: medium wash barrel leg jeans laid flat with a cream sweater, gold hoops and brown loafers

I’ll admit it. I resisted the barrel jean trend for a while, and now I’m completely hooked. The curved leg looks so cool with a cozy sweater and loafers. If you’ve been eyeing the cult favorite pair, you’re going to love these Free People Good Luck barrel jeans alternatives. The We The Free Good Luck Mid-Rise Barrel Jeans run $98 to $128.

That’s not crazy for denim, but trend pieces are more fun when the price is low. I found 5 barrel leg jeans from Amazon and Walmart with that same rounded silhouette. Prices start at just $16.98.

Why Everyone Loves the Free People Good Luck Barrel Jeans

The Good Luck jeans went viral because the shape is both relaxed and flattering. For reference, the We The Free Good Luck Mid-Rise Barrel Jeans are $98 to $128 on the Free People site right now. Here’s what fans love about them:

  • Curved barrel leg: the leg bows out at the knee and tapers at the ankle for that rounded shape.
  • Mid rise: it sits comfortably at the waist without feeling tight.
  • Cropped length: the ankle length shows off boots, flats and sneakers.
  • Vintage washes: soft, worn in blues look like a thrift store find.
  • Relaxed fit: they feel as comfortable as sweatpants, but they look polished.

What to Look for in a Free People Good Luck Barrel Jeans Alternative

Barrel jeans can look amazing or a little off, depending on a few details. Here’s what I’d check.

  • Leg shape: look for a true curve through the knee. Straight wide legs aren’t the same look.
  • Rise: mid rise feels closest to the Good Luck jeans. High rise works if you like to tuck in tops.
  • Inseam: barrel jeans look best when they hit right at the ankle. Check the inseam for your height.
  • Stretch: a little stretch adds comfort. Rigid denim holds the barrel shape better.
  • Wash: light and medium vintage washes look the most like the original.

The 5 Best Free People Good Luck Barrel Jeans Alternatives

Levi’s Women’s Cinch Barrel Jeans, $63.71

Levi's Women's Cinch Barrel Jeans from Amazon, a Free People Good Luck barrel jeans alternative

Shop at Amazon

Levi’s Cinch Barrel jeans are the most polished pick here. Levi’s knows denim, and this pair has a sculpted, curved barrel leg. It has a 4.4 star rating from over 400 reviewers.

The fit is a bit more tailored than the Free People pair. Still, it’s a great choice if you want classic quality and a slightly dressier look.

Best for: quality denim from a classic brand.

loveimgs Mid Rise Barrel Jeans, $37.99

loveimgs Mid Rise Barrel Jeans from Amazon, a Free People Good Luck barrel jeans alternative

Shop at Amazon

These loveimgs barrel jeans are a top seller with nearly 2,500 reviews. They have a mid rise, a stretchy fabric and a vintage wash, which is very close to the Good Luck vibe.

Their 4.0 star rating is a little lower than some others. That’s why I’d check the size chart carefully before ordering. At under $40, though, they’re a fun way to try the trend.

Best for: the closest mid rise look.

Flowyair High Waisted Baggy Barrel Jeans, $42.99

Flowyair High Waisted Baggy Barrel Jeans from Amazon, a Free People Good Luck barrel jeans alternative

Shop at Amazon

Flowyair’s baggy barrel jeans have a high waist and a really dramatic curve. The raw hem gives them a cool, undone finish. They have a 4.4 star rating from about 95 reviewers.

If you love an exaggerated barrel shape, this is the one I’d grab first. Pair them with a fitted top so the jeans can be the star.

Best for: a dramatic barrel shape.

Scenario High Rise Barrel Jeans, $24.98

Scenario High Rise Barrel Jeans from Walmart, a Free People Good Luck barrel jeans alternative

Shop at Walmart

Scenario’s high rise barrel jeans are a Walmart find at just $24.98. They come in regular and short inseams, plus a wide size range from 0 to 28W. The pair pictured is a soft olive, and the listing shows other washes too.

They have over 900 reviews with a 4.4 star rating. That’s a lot of happy shoppers for the price. Plus, the inclusive sizing makes them easy to recommend.

Best for: inclusive sizing on a budget.

No Boundaries Ultra Baggy Barrel Jeans, $16.98

No Boundaries Ultra Baggy Barrel Jeans from Walmart, a Free People Good Luck barrel jeans alternative

Shop at Walmart

No Boundaries Ultra Baggy Barrel jeans are the lowest price pick at $16.98. They come in three inseams and sizes from 00 to 4X. The fit is roomy and relaxed, so they feel super comfortable.

They have over 300 reviews and a 4.3 star average. The look is baggier than the Good Luck jeans, so you may want to size down for a closer fit. Still, the price is hard to beat.

Best for: the lowest price.

How to Style Your Barrel Jeans

Barrel jeans look best with a little balance on top and a sleek shoe. Here are four easy outfits:

  • Sweater and loafers: a chunky cream sweater, gold hoops and brown loafers is my go to fall look.
  • Fitted tee and sneakers: a tucked in baby tee keeps the outfit balanced for weekend errands.
  • Blazer and boots: add an oversized blazer and western ankle boots for dinner with friends.
  • Ballet flats: slim flats show off the cropped hem and make the look feel feminine.

Need boots to go with them? My Ganni boots alternatives look amazing with a cropped barrel hem. For flats, check out my Miu Miu ballet flats alternatives.

Barrel Jeans vs. Wide Leg Jeans

These two styles look similar on a hanger, but they fit very differently. Wide leg jeans fall straight down from the hip and stay wide at the hem. Barrel jeans curve out at the knee and then narrow again near the ankle.

That curve is what gives barrel jeans their rounded, horseshoe shape. It also makes them easier to wear with flats and ankle boots, since the hem doesn’t swallow your shoes.

If you already own wide leg jeans, a barrel pair adds something new to your rotation. Plus, the cropped length works year round, from sandals in spring to boots in winter.

How to Find Your Size in Barrel Jeans

Barrel jeans are meant to fit loose through the leg, but they should still fit at the waist. Start with your usual size, then check the waist and inseam measurements on each listing.

If you’re petite, look for short inseams like the Scenario pair. Taller friends should look at the 32.5 or 34.5 inch No Boundaries options. Also, remember that rigid denim won’t stretch much, so don’t size down too far.

Frequently Asked Questions

What jeans are similar to the Free People Good Luck barrel jeans?

The loveimgs mid rise barrel jeans are the closest match in rise and wash. The Flowyair jeans have an even more dramatic curve. For a polished option, try the Levi’s Cinch Barrel jeans.

Does Walmart have a Free People Good Luck jeans look alike?

Yes! The Scenario High Rise Barrel Jeans and the No Boundaries Ultra Baggy Barrel Jeans are both at Walmart. Both are under $25.

Are barrel jeans flattering?

Barrel jeans can be very flattering when the rise and length are right. A cropped hem that hits at the ankle and a fitted top keep the look balanced.

Should I size up or down in barrel jeans?

Most barrel jeans are cut roomy, so many shoppers stick with their true size. If you want a less baggy fit, especially in No Boundaries, size down one.

Final Thoughts

If I had to pick one, the loveimgs mid rise barrel jeans are the closest to the Good Luck jeans for the price. For the best quality, I’d choose the Levi’s Cinch Barrel. Then, for the lowest price, the No Boundaries pair is a steal at $16.98.

Find even more designer looks for less in my ultimate guide to designer alternatives.

Disclosure: Please note that some of the links above are affiliate links. At no additional cost to you, I will earn a commission if you purchase after clicking through the link.

You May Also Like

Love Free People style? Don’t miss my Free People Easy Street tunic alternatives, which look so cute with barrel jeans. My Agolde 90s jeans alternatives are perfect if you want a straighter leg too.

Leave a Comment