6 Balsam Hill Christmas Tree Alternatives You Will Love for Less

Balsam Hill Christmas tree alternatives: a lit artificial tree with cream and gold ornaments in a cozy living room

Every year, the day after Thanksgiving, my kids beg to put up the tree. We put on Christmas music, make hot cocoa, and pull out the ornaments. A full, realistic tree makes that moment feel magical. The Balsam Hill trees are gorgeous, but they can cost as much as a new couch. So I rounded up the best Balsam Hill Christmas tree alternatives that look just as full for a lot less.

Balsam Hill is known for lifelike branches and bright, even lighting. You can get a similar look at home without spending $800. Below you’ll find 6 pre-lit 7.5 foot trees from Amazon and Walmart, starting at just $98. There’s a classic green fir, a snowy flocked pine and a few full, fluffy options in between.

Why Everyone Loves Balsam Hill Christmas Trees

Balsam Hill trees are known for looking real, even up close. The brand molds many of its branch tips from real trees, and the lights are built right in. For reference, the popular Vermont White Spruce is $799 right now in the 7.5 foot size.

  • Realistic needles: the branch tips are shaped to look like real spruce and fir.
  • Full shape: the trees have dense branches, so you see fewer gaps.
  • Pre-lit options: the lights come strung through the branches, which saves so much time.
  • Many styles: you can pick slim, full, flocked or classic green trees.
  • Easy setup: the sections connect quickly, and many trees have hinged branches.

What to Look for in a Balsam Hill Christmas Tree Alternative

A great artificial tree is an investment, even at a lower price. Here’s what I’d look for before you buy.

  • Branch tips: more tips usually means a fuller tree. Look for the tip count on the listing.
  • Height and width: measure your ceiling and floor space first. A 7.5 foot tree fits most rooms with 8 foot ceilings.
  • Lights: decide between warm white, multicolor or color changing lights. Warm white looks the most classic.
  • Shape: full trees feel cozy, while pencil or slim trees fit small spaces.
  • Reviews: read photos from real buyers. They show how fluffy the tree looks once it’s shaped.

The 6 Best Balsam Hill Christmas Tree Alternatives

Holiday Time 7.5′ Pre-Lit Kennedy Fir Tree, $98.00

Holiday Time pre-lit Kennedy Fir artificial tree from Walmart, a Balsam Hill Christmas tree alternative

Shop at Walmart

The Holiday Time Kennedy Fir is one of Walmart’s best selling trees, and the price is amazing. It’s a 7.5 foot pre-lit green fir with color changing LED lights. That means you can switch between warm white and multicolor.

It has a 4.6 star rating from more than 1,000 reviews. It also has a quick set design, so the sections connect fast. For under $100, this is the one I’d grab first.

Best for: the best value full size tree.

Hykolity 7.5 ft Prelit Christmas Tree, $119.99

Hykolity 7.5 foot prelit artificial Christmas tree from Amazon, a Balsam Hill Christmas tree alternative

Shop at Amazon

Hykolity’s 7.5 foot prelit tree is a top seller on Amazon, with more than 2,000 ratings. It comes with 450 multicolor LEDs, so it has a fun, nostalgic glow. The branches are hinged, which makes setup much easier.

Reviewers say it looks full once you fluff the branches. Just plan on 20 to 30 minutes of shaping for the best look.

Best for: a classic multicolor Christmas look.

Best Choice Products 7.5 ft Flocked Pre-Lit Pine, $179.99

Best Choice Products flocked pre-lit pine tree from Walmart, a Balsam Hill flocked tree look alike

Shop at Walmart

If you love the snowy look of a flocked Balsam Hill tree, this is your pick. The Best Choice Products flocked pine has a full layer of white flocking and 550 twinkling lights. It looks like it was just dusted with snow.

It has more than 5,300 reviews at Walmart with a 4.4 star average. Some reviewers note that the flocking sheds a little at first, so set it up over a tree skirt.

Best for: a snowy, flocked farmhouse Christmas look.

Yaheetech 7.5 ft Pre-Lit Christmas Tree, $104.99

Yaheetech 7.5 foot pre-lit Christmas tree from Amazon, a Balsam Hill Christmas tree alternative

Shop at Amazon

The Yaheetech 7.5 foot pre-lit tree comes with 550 warm white lights. That warm glow is very close to the classic Balsam Hill look. Then it has a sturdy metal stand that holds it steady.

It has a 4.5 star rating from more than 2,800 ratings on Amazon. It’s a great middle option if you want warm white lights at a low price.

Best for: warm white lights on a budget.

Holiday Time 7.5′ Pre-Lit Milford Pine Tree, $189.00

Holiday Time pre-lit Milford Pine artificial tree from Walmart, a Balsam Hill Christmas tree alternative

Shop at Walmart

The Holiday Time Milford Pine is a step up in fullness. It’s a 7.5 foot pre-lit pine with a lush, rounded shape. Also, it has more than 1,200 reviews at Walmart with a 4.6 star average.

I love this one for a living room with tall windows. It looks so full and inviting with simple glass ornaments.

Best for: a fuller pine shape without the luxury price.

National Tree Company 7.5 ft Downswept Douglas Fir, $227.20

National Tree Company pre-lit Downswept Douglas Fir tree from Amazon, a Balsam Hill Christmas tree look alike

Shop at Amazon

National Tree Company is a longtime favorite for artificial trees. This Downswept Douglas Fir has branches that angle down, just like a real fir. That gives it a natural, graceful shape.

It has close to 4,000 ratings on Amazon. It’s the priciest pick here, but it’s still far less than a Balsam Hill tree.

Best for: the most natural looking branch shape.

How to Decorate Your Balsam Hill Christmas Tree Alternative

A little styling makes any tree look high end. Here are my favorite ideas.

  • Fluff every branch: separate each tip and point some up and some out. This one step makes a budget tree look so much fuller.
  • Neutral and gold: mix cream, gold and soft green ornaments with a knit tree skirt. Add a velvet stocking set from my Pottery Barn velvet stocking look alikes on the mantel.
  • Add a real scent: artificial trees don’t smell like pine. Light a fir candle from my Thymes Frasier Fir candle alternatives nearby.
  • Layer in texture: tuck in ribbon, picks and a few large ornaments deep in the branches. It fills gaps and adds depth.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best Balsam Hill Christmas tree alternative?

The Holiday Time Kennedy Fir is the best value at under $100. If you want a fuller shape, the Holiday Time Milford Pine is a great step up. Both are 7.5 foot pre-lit trees.

Does Walmart sell trees that look like Balsam Hill?

Yes. Walmart’s Holiday Time trees and the Best Choice Products flocked pine all have full shapes and built in lights. They cost a fraction of the original.

Does Amazon have a Balsam Hill look alike?

Amazon has several. The National Tree Company Downswept Douglas Fir has the most natural shape. The Yaheetech tree is a great pick for warm white lights.

Is a Balsam Hill tree worth the price?

Balsam Hill trees are beautiful and built to last. Still, with good fluffing and decor, the trees above can look just as cozy. I’d save the difference for ornaments and gifts.

How do you make an artificial Christmas tree look more expensive?

Start by fluffing every branch, working from the bottom up. Then add a second strand of warm white lights deep inside the tree for extra glow. Next, use fewer colors and more texture, like ribbon, wood beads and glass. Finally, finish with a full tree skirt or collar to hide the stand. These small steps make a $98 tree look like it came from a high end catalog.

Final Thoughts

If I had to pick, the Holiday Time Kennedy Fir is the best value Balsam Hill Christmas tree alternative. Then, for the most natural shape, I’d go with the National Tree Company Downswept Douglas Fir. And for a snowy farmhouse look, the Best Choice Products flocked pine is so pretty.

Discover more designer looks for less in my ultimate guide to designer alternatives.

Disclosure: Please note that some of the links above are affiliate links. At no additional cost to you, I will earn a commission if you purchase after clicking through the link.

You May Also Like

Decorating for the holidays? Don’t miss my Mr. Christmas ceramic tree alternatives, which add such a sweet vintage touch. My Pottery Barn faux fur throw alternatives will make your living room extra cozy too.

Leave a Comment