Is there anything cozier than a row of plush velvet stockings hanging on the mantel? Pottery Barn’s velvet stockings are some of the prettiest out there, with rich color, soft cuffs and that classic monogram. But at around $35 to $50 each, outfitting the whole family (plus the dog) gets expensive fast. That’s why I went hunting for the best Pottery Barn velvet stocking look alike options, and I found some beautiful ones starting at just $7.
It’s the perfect time to order, since personalized stockings can take a little longer to arrive once the holiday rush begins.
Why We Love Pottery Barn Velvet Stockings
Pottery Barn’s stockings feel special because of the details. The velvet is soft and has a beautiful sheen, the cuffs are a contrasting color that’s perfect for a name or monogram, and the oversized shape leaves plenty of room for gifts. They come in classic red, ivory, emerald and blush, plus quilted, scalloped and bow styles that look so elegant together.
What to Look for in a Velvet Stocking Look Alike
- Rich velvet: Look for a thick velvet with a soft sheen rather than thin felt.
- A contrasting cuff: An ivory or white cuff gives you that classic Pottery Barn look and shows off a name beautifully.
- Size: Most Pottery Barn stockings are about 20 inches or larger. Check the measurements so everything fits.
- Personalization: Embroidered names look the most polished and turn your stockings into keepsakes.
- A sturdy loop: A strong hanging loop keeps a heavy stocking from slipping off its holder.
Quick Picks at a Glance
- Closest overall look: ELEGANTPARK Personalized Velvet Stocking, about $15.
- Best for a big family: Embroidered Velvet Stocking, about $7.
- Best blank stocking: Getwin 20 Inch Velvet Stocking, about $8.
- Best bow detail: Holiday Time Velvet Bow Stocking, about $10.
- Best set: My Texas House Ruffle Velvet Stockings, two for about $33.
The 5 Best Pottery Barn Velvet Stocking Look Alikes
ELEGANTPARK Personalized Velvet Christmas Stocking, $14.99
This is the closest match to Pottery Barn’s classic velvet stocking for the price. It’s a big 20 inch velvet stocking with a contrasting cuff, and you can add a custom name so it looks like a keepsake.
It comes in classic black and white combinations that look so chic on a modern farmhouse mantel. It’s newer, so there are only a few reviews, but they’re all five stars.
Best for: a large, personalized velvet stocking under $15.
Personalized Embroidered Velvet Christmas Stocking, $6.99
Need a stocking for everyone in the family? At $6.99 each, this embroidered velvet stocking makes that so easy. It’s 18 inches with a sweet bow, the velvet is thick and soft, and there are more than 10 colors and patterns so you can match or mix.
It has a 4.8 star rating from over 60 reviewers, which is a great sign at this price.
Best for: personalizing a whole family set on a budget.
Getwin 20 Inch Velvet Christmas Stocking, $7.58
If you want the look of Pottery Barn’s solid velvet stockings without a name, this one is such a steal. It’s a full 20 inches with a felt lining, so it holds its shape when you fill it.
The plain cuff is perfect for a clip on monogram or a little name tag (more on that below).
Best for: a simple, solid velvet stocking for under $10.
Holiday Time Christmas Stocking with Velvet Bow, $9.97
Pottery Barn’s velvet bow stockings are so charming, and this Walmart find gives you a similar look for under $10. The oversized red velvet bow pops against the white stocking, and it would look adorable on a staircase or a kids’ bedroom door.
It’s not personalized, but you can easily add a name tag or a monogram ornament.
Best for: the lowest price and a festive bow detail.
My Texas House Ruffle Red Velvet Christmas Stockings, Set of 2, $33.32
These are made with soft Dutch velvet and have a romantic ruffle cuff that reminds me of Pottery Barn’s scalloped velvet stocking. At about $17 each, they’re a great value if you need several stockings for a big family.
Best for: a set with a pretty ruffle cuff and great value.
Tips for a Pottery Barn Inspired Mantel
- Stick to two or three colors: Red and ivory or emerald and blush always look intentional.
- Mix textures: Pair smooth velvet with a chunky knit or quilted stocking for depth.
- Add greenery: A faux garland with warm string lights makes any stocking look more expensive.
- Use weighted holders: Brass or gold stocking holders add a polished finishing touch.
- Fill them early: Tissue paper inside each stocking keeps the shape full for photos.
Need ideas for what to put inside? See my favorite luxury stocking stuffers that look designer for less.
Easy Ways to Personalize Stockings Without Embroidery
Not every stocking on this list comes personalized, but it’s so easy to add a custom touch yourself. Here are a few ideas I love:
- Name tags: Tie a wooden, leather or brass tag to the hanging loop with a velvet ribbon.
- Monogram ornaments: Clip a gold initial ornament right onto the cuff for an elegant, Pottery Barn inspired look.
- Iron on letters: Glitter or velvet iron on letters work well on cotton cuffs. Test a small spot first, since velvet can be sensitive to heat.
- Pet stockings: Add a paw print charm or a small bone shaped tag so your fur babies feel included too.
These small details make a budget friendly set feel custom, and you can switch them out every year as your family grows.
Hosting this year? My favorite party cheese boards make the whole room feel festive next to that pretty mantel.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much are Pottery Barn velvet stockings?
Pottery Barn velvet stockings usually cost about $25 to $50 each depending on the style, plus an extra fee for personalization. Sale prices vary throughout the holiday season.
What is the best Pottery Barn velvet stocking look alike?
The ELEGANTPARK Personalized Velvet Christmas Stocking on Amazon is my favorite Pottery Barn velvet stocking look alike. It’s a large 20 inch velvet stocking with a contrasting cuff and a custom name for about $15.
When should I order personalized stockings?
Order personalized stockings by mid November if you can. Embroidery adds production time, and shipping slows down closer to the holidays.
How do you clean velvet stockings?
Spot clean velvet with a damp cloth and mild soap, then let it air dry. Store your stockings flat or rolled in tissue so the velvet doesn’t crease.
Are velvet stockings worth it?
Velvet stockings feel more luxurious than felt or knit, and a well made one can last for many holiday seasons. If you want an heirloom look on a budget, a personalized velvet stocking from Amazon is a lovely middle ground.
Final Thoughts
You can absolutely get that cozy Pottery Barn mantel for less. If I had to pick, I’d go with the ELEGANTPARK stocking for the closest look, the $6.99 embroidered velvet stocking for a big family set, and the My Texas House ruffle stockings for that scalloped Pottery Barn feel.
Discover more of my favorite designer look alikes in my guide to the best designer look alikes of the year.
Disclosure: Please note that some of the links above are affiliate links. At no additional cost to you, I will earn a commission if you purchase after clicking through the link.
You May Also Like
Decorating the whole house for the holidays? Don’t miss my Pottery Barn look alikes and alternatives for pillows, throws and decor that look just as cozy for less.
